(lost) Holmes & Watson - Criterion - lost

Holmes & Watson - Criterion Holmes & Watson - Criterion - lost

Erection date: 3/1/1953


This plaque commemorates the historic meeting early in 1881 at the original Criterion Long Bar, of Dr Stamford and Dr John H. Watson which led to the introduction of Dr Watson to Mr Sherlock Holmes.

{Below is a small rectangular plaque, illegible in the photo, but it probably names the erector of the plaque, the Tokio Sherlock Holmes Society.}

The presence of Sherlock Holmes at this unveiling is rather misleading since he was not present at the event commemorated. In Conan Doyle's story Watson met the go-between Dr Stamford at the Criterion and was taken by him to Barts and it is there that the famous meeting took place.

Our picture source, Alamy, (incorrectly) captions the photo: "English actor Carleton Hobbs, dressed as Sherlock Holmes, with ex-Chief Inspector Fabian, of Scotland Yard, witnesses the unveiling of a plaque recording his character's meeting with Dr Watson at the long bar at the Criterion Restaurant in Piccadilly Circus, London, in 1851 {sic}. The plaque is the gift of the Tokio Sherlock Holmes Society."

Other photos at Alamy show Sherlock departing in a horse-drawn hansom cab - so it was quite an event.

The Arthur Conan Doyle Encylopedia has a video showing Sherlock arriving and unveiling the plaque, and informs "The plaque was an idea of Mr. Richard Hughes, an Australian sherlockian (resident in Tokyo), and offered by the Tokyo branch of The Baker Street Irregulars."

In 1953 when this plaque was unveiled the radio Sherlock Holmes series, that was to run for a massive 75 episodes, was in its first year; Carleton Hobbs was a little-known actor with only a few minor credits to his name; Fabian had published his book 3 years previously, and it would be dramatised by the BBC, beginning the following year.

Site: Holmes & Watson - Criterion (2 memorials)

W1, 224 Piccadilly, 224, Criterion Restaurant

The Criterion Restaurant is on the ground floor with the entrance at the left of our photo.

The meeting at the Criterion took place on New Year's Day in 1881, 72 years and 2 days before the first, lost, plaque was erected.  The current plaque, erected to mark the centenary of the meeting, is inside, on the wall to the right, before the tables begin. It was brought to our attention by Londonist.

The meeting at the Criterion is described in the first Sherlock Holmes story "A Study in Scarlett" published in 1887. See the plaque at Barts Hospital for the actual meeting of Holmes and Watson.

This section lists the subjects commemorated on the memorial on this page:
Holmes & Watson - Criterion - lost

Subjects commemorated Information

Sherlock Holmes

Originally named Sheridan Hope, then Sherringford Holmes and finally Sherlock...

Read More

Dr Watson

John H. Watson, MD, friend of Sherlock Holmes.

Read More

This section lists the subjects who helped to create/erect the memorial on this page:
Holmes & Watson - Criterion - lost

Created by Information

Tokyo Sherlock Holmes Society

Active in 1953. Initiated by Richard Hughes and also known as the Baritsu Cha...

Read More

Robert Fabian

Robert Honey Fabian was born in Lewisham. He joined the police in 1921 and ro...

Read More

Carleton Hobbs

Hobbo (as he was known) portrayed Sherlock Holmes in 80 radio adaptations in ...

Read More

Richard Hughes (journalist)

Richard Joseph Hughes CBE was an Australian journalist who spent much of his ...

Read More

This section lists the other memorials at the same location as the memorial on this page:
Holmes & Watson - Criterion - lost

Also at this site Information

Holmes & Watson - Criterion

Here, New Years Day, 1881, at the Criterion Long Bar, Stamford, dresser at Ba...

Read More

Nearby Memorials

Kenneth Grahame

Kenneth Grahame

W8, Phillimore Place, 16

This street was called Durham Villas in Grahame's time. This was his London home when his son was born and while "The Wind in the Willow...

2 subjects commemorated, 1 creator
RNH - Princess Louise

RNH - Princess Louise

N7, Manor Gardens, Royal Northern Gardens

In 1997, as a condition of developing the RNH site, Bellway Homes (the developer) was required to create one acre of public open space - ...

1 subject commemorated, 1 creator
School Committee

School Committee

N1, Bletchley Street

Boys is given as the Incumbent and Barclay as the Treasurer. This is an attractive plaque, designed into the building. Pity about the pig...

10 subjects commemorated
Gerald Road Police Station

Gerald Road Police Station

SW1, Gerald Road, 60

The lamp here has lost its blueness. Caroline's Miscellany explains that the practice of hanging blue lamps outside police stations start...

2 subjects commemorated
Archbishop of Canterbury

Archbishop of Canterbury

SE1, Cornwall Road

We were expecting the phrase "May they have peace who dwell therein" to be a quote from the Bible but we can't find it.

1 subject commemorated